Constitutional and Legal Infirmities of the Judgment Purporting to Nullify the Leadership of Senator David Mark and the Candidacy of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar.
1.INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY
It is our opinion that the aforesaid judgment of the Federal High Court is vulnerable to being set aside on appeal on the following grounds:The trial court lacked jurisdiction, the subject matter being a non-justiciable internal affair of a political party.The judgment misapplies the Constitution of the ADC.The nomination of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar is protected by law and cannot be indirectly nullified through a leadership dispute.The judgment breaches the right to fair hearing, as Alhaji Atiku Abubakar was not joined, and the plaintiff lacks locus standi.The suit constitutes forum shopping and an abuse of court process in light of subsisting judgments of courts of coordinate jurisdiction.Each ground is considered below.
2.LACK OF JURISDICTION: INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF A POLITICAL PARTY
It is settled law, up to the Supreme Court, that the leadership, membership and management of a political party are the internal affairs of the party and are not justiciable. Section 83(5-6) of the Electoral Act 2026 categorically provides as follows:(5) Subject to the provision of subsection (3), no Court in Nigeria shall entertain jurisdiction over any suit or matter pertaining to the internal affairs of a political party. (6) Where such action is brought in negation of this provision – (a) no interim or interlocutory injunction shall be entertained by the Court, but the Court shall suspend its ruling and deliver it at the stage of final judgment and shall give accelerated hearing to the matter. (b) the Court shall, at the conclusion of the matter, impose costs of not less than ₦10,000,000.00 on the counsel who filed the action and not less than ₦10,000,000.00 on the Plaintiff/Applicant and in addition to payment to the Commission of any cost, including solicitors’ fees incurred by it where joined as a party.The Supreme Court in EYITAYO JEGEDE V. INEC (2021) 14 NWLR (PT. 1790), APC V. MARAFA (2019) held respectively that courts have no jurisdiction to determine who should be Chairman or Secretary of a political party. The plaintiff’s claim is, in substance, a leadership tussle arising from the resignation of Ralph Nwosu. A Federal High Court cannot impose a chairman on a political party. Articles 14 and 15 of the ADC Constitution provide for the National Executive Committee (NEC) to constitute a Caretaker Committee where a vacancy occurs, and this is what was done. A court cannot rewrite a party’s constitution for it.
3.MISAPPLICATION OF THE ADC CONSTITUTION
The plaintiff relies on automatic succession by the Deputy National Chairman. That provision is inapplicable, for the following reasons:The entire National Working Committee (NWC) led by Ralph Nwosu resigned en bloc, not merely the Chairman. There was no NWC left over which a Deputy Chairman could preside.Article 18(4) of the ADC Constitution empowers NEC to dissolve the NWC and appoint a Caretaker Committee in an emergency.The meeting that appointed Senator David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola was duly convened by the Board of Trustees (BOT) and NEC, the highest organs of the party, with attendance exceeding 90%.A right of succession cannot be claimed in respect of an office that no longer exists
4.THE CANDIDACY OF ALHAJI ATIKU ABUBAKAR IS PROTECTED BY LAW
Assuming without conceding, there were a defect in the constitution of the Caretaker Committee, the nomination of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar is protected on three footings:Section 84 of the Electoral Act. Alhaji Abubakar emerged from a Presidential Primary monitored by INEC, conducted with delegates as the law requires. INEC, the 2nd Defendant in the suit, monitored the primary and published his name. A leadership dispute does not vitiate a primary conducted under Section 84.The principle in Eyitayo Jegede. The Supreme Court held that an irregularity affecting a party’s executive does not invalidate a candidacy produced by the party. The candidate is not a party to the executive’s internal dispute.INEC’s publication is prima facie evidence of validity. INEC has published Alhaji Abubakar as the ADC Presidential Candidate for the 16 January 2027 election after verifying compliance with Sections 82 to 84 of the Electoral Act. Under Section 285(14) of the Constitution, a candidacy may be challenged only in a pre-election matter before the Federal High Court, initiated by an aspirant who participated in the primary. Mr. Nafiu Bala Gombe was not an aspirant and has no standing to do so.
5.Fatal Defects: Locus Standi and Non-JoinderLocus standi.
The plaintiff resigned or otherwise ceased to be a member of the NWC before the suit was filed. He cannot challenge the affairs of a party in which he no longer holds office, particularly where the suit serves personal ambition.Non-joinder and fair hearing. More fundamentally, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, whose candidacy is directly affected, was not joined as a party to Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025. A person’s nomination cannot be nullified without affording him a hearing. This violates the right to fair hearing under Section 36 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) and, in our opinion, renders the judgment a nullity.
6.Forum Shopping and Abuse of Court Process
There are at least three subsisting judgments of courts of coordinate jurisdiction affirming the leadership of Senator David Mark. Under the principle of stare decisis and the settled rule of judicial comity, the learned trial Judge, Lifu J., cannot sit on appeal over the decisions of his brother Judges. The proper course for any aggrieved party is to appeal to the Court of Appeal, not to procure a conflicting judgment. The suit amounts to forum shopping and an abuse of court process.
7.Conclusion and Opinion
The judgment is, in our view, an instance of judicial overreach into the internal democracy of a political party. It is vulnerable to being set aside on appeal because it:Was delivered without jurisdiction;Is contrary to the weight of Supreme Court authority;Violates the right to fair hearing; andIs incapable of nullifying a candidacy validly monitored and published by INEC under the Electoral Act.Accordingly, it is our opinion that Alhaji Atiku Abubakar remains the validly nominated Presidential Candidate of the ADC, and that the party remains on the ballot for the 2027 general election.





































